Picture Books for Upper Elementary: Why They’re Complex Enough

Picture books for upper elementary students belong in your classroom, and I’ll happily make the case to anyone who asks. A while back, I overheard teachers debating whether picture books were appropriate for 5th and 6th grade. I held my tongue then, but I don’t have to here: yes, use picture books! Here’s why they’re complex enough for older students, and four reasons they make great mentor texts in grades 3-6.

Picture books for upper elementary: picture books are for everyone

This post contains affiliate links to books on Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Are picture books complex enough for older students?

This is the question I hear most, and my answer is always yes. A text’s complexity is about much more than its level (whether that’s a Lexile measure, an AR level, or a guided reading level). Text complexity is usually measured three ways:

  • Quantitative: the numbers, like a Lexile measure.
  • Qualitative: the levels of meaning, structure, language, and knowledge the text requires.
  • Reader and task: what your students bring to the text, like background knowledge, vocabulary, and experiences, and what you ask them to do with it.

When I led a staff development session on text complexity, I used a s’mores graphic I found on Pinterest. Teachers came up with their own reasons for each layer. The graham crackers are the reader and task, because they’re the foundation that holds everything together. The marshmallow is qualitative, because it’s fluffy and changes shape, like all the things you can’t measure. The chocolate is quantitative, because it’s solid and fits right on the graham cracker.

Text complexity s’more graphic: reader and task, qualitative, and quantitative measures

Picture books are a lot like Disney and Pixar movies. A kindergartner enjoys the story, while a ten-year-old picks up on themes the little ones miss, the same way adults laugh at jokes that go over kids’ heads.

The Other Side

The Other Side by Jacqueline Woodson book cover

The Other Side by Jacqueline Woodson, illustrated by E. B. Lewis

Get the book on Amazon

The Other Side is a great example. Its Lexile measure is in the primary range, so if you went strictly by the number, you might skip it for upper grades. But how many six-year-olds would pick up on the fence as a metaphor? The book opens deep conversations about segregation that older students are ready for.

You add the rigor

You, the teacher, are one of the biggest factors in a text’s complexity. You can raise the rigor of any picture book by asking the right questions.

  1. Choose a book that fits your standard. Pick a picture book that relates to the skill you’re teaching.
  2. Ask questions as you read. Pause for comprehension questions that show students how to think while they read.
  3. Think aloud. Share your own thoughts and feelings about the text, so students hear what a strong reader does.

Text-dependent questions keep students in the text, so they prove their answers with evidence instead of personal connections. I share question stems and an anchor chart for this in my text dependent questions post.

Go deeperInteractive read-alouds build this thinking into every read. My Interactive Read-Aloud mini-course shows the what, why, and how.

Four reasons to use picture books in upper elementary

  1. They’re short and sweet. Most picture books finish in 32 pages, so students remember the story when you refer back to it. You can read a great book one day and use it for lessons for days after, often for several standards.
  2. They hold students’ attention. The illustrations and vivid language keep students engaged. Some of the best examples of figurative language, vivid verbs, and sensory details I’ve found come from picture books.
  3. They integrate content. Historical fiction, nonfiction, science fiction, and math literature let you teach reading and writing while you cover social studies, science, and math.
  4. They build exposure to many styles. Novels still matter, because students need to build stamina with a longer story. But they also need to see, hear, and understand many styles of writing to grow as readers and writers, and picture books give them that all year.

I also kept a books of the month shelf in my 4th grade classroom, filled with seasonal picture books. All of my students, my strongest and my most reluctant readers, loved visiting that shelf.

Picture books I used with upper elementary students

For personal narrative

For figurative language and sensory details

For social studies and science

  • Encounter by Jane Yolen: Columbus’s landing from a Taíno boy’s point of view.
  • Katie’s Trunk by Ann Turner: the American Revolution from a Loyalist family’s view.
  • Cloud Dance by Thomas Locker: different kinds of clouds in paintings and poetic text, for a weather unit.
  • Water Dance by Thomas Locker: the water cycle in paintings and poetic text.

Picture book resources for upper elementary

That’s exactly why I created Better Than Basal: reading activities and writing prompts that get several standards out of the picture books you already read aloud. For grades 3-5, choose from Volume 1 (40 read alouds), Volume 2 (30), Volume 3 (40), Nonfiction (10), and Celebrating Diversity (10).

Keep reading

Want more ideas like these? Find resources by grade and topic.

Jivey signature