Text Dependent Questions: Climbing the TDQ Pyramid With Close Reading

Text dependent questions can only be answered by going back into the text. They push students past what they remember to what the author actually wrote and meant. When I taught close reading, my students had become annotating experts, so I started giving their annotations a focus with text dependent questions. Here’s how we climbed the TDQ pyramid with one pair of passages over several days, plus a free set of question stems.

Text dependent questions with annotations during close reading

What are text dependent questions?

Text dependent questions build in layers, often shown as a pyramid. Students start with what the text says and work up to what it means. Each new close read lets you ask a deeper question about the same text.

What does the text say?

Key details and explicit evidence.

How does the text work?

Vocabulary, structure, and the author’s purpose.

What does the text mean?

Inferences and connections across texts.

Text dependent questions pyramid

Image: Teaching It Forward

Give annotations a focus

My students already knew how to annotate (here’s how I taught it). Text dependent questions gave them something specific to look for. While we studied the Founding Fathers in social studies, I used the George Washington passage from my February and March paired texts.

I wanted students to decide what kind of person George Washington was based on the evidence. In other words, they had to infer from what the passage said. Here are some of their inferences:

Student inferences about George Washington from text evidence
More student inferences about George Washington with evidence

Background and clip art: Teaching Super Power

What does the text say?

To climb the pyramid, we used the same pair of passages from my Mysteries of the Deep paired texts for several days. We started with a compare and contrast question. Students wrote out specific, explicit evidence from the passage to build their answer.

Compare and contrast text dependent question with explicit evidence

Keep in mindUse one text for several days so each close read can go deeper.

How does the text work?

On another day, we asked, “What does the author want us to know about the giant squid?” Students recognized it as an author’s purpose question.

Author’s purpose text dependent question about the giant squid

Then we turned to the second passage. Many students had seen an anglerfish in a movie, but what about readers who hadn’t? That led to a great talk about why images in articles can be necessary.

Text dependent question about why images in articles are necessary

What does the text mean? Constructed responses

All of those questions prepared students for the top of the pyramid: “How do animals survive in the deepest part of the ocean?” It sounds simple, but students had to infer using both passages. Both explained how deep sea animals find food: the giant squid’s large eyes help it see in the dark and its tentacles catch prey, and bioluminescent animals attract prey. Students put that together to discuss, then write.

Student constructed response citing evidence from two passages

This response isn’t perfect, but I was so proud of this student. English wasn’t her first language, and she worked hard to cite evidence and answer the question completely.

Text dependent question stems

I love having a bank of questions ready instead of racking my brain for them. This free resource by Beth Burke has question stems for all kinds of reading standards, and it’s a lifesaver if you do close reading.

Two pins helped me, too: one matches question types to the reading standards, and one is an anchor chart for proving an answer with evidence from the text.

Text-dependent question stems matched to reading standards
Anchor chart for proving an answer with evidence from the text

Paired texts used in this post

Both are paired texts for grades 4-6, and Mysteries of the Deep also comes in a grades 2-3 version.

Keep reading

Jivey signature