Mentor Sentences Data: Case Study

What does the data say about mentor sentences? A mentor sentences case study from Ideas by Jivey comparing beginning and end of year writing samples.

If you’ve been considering using mentor sentences and need more proof than the feedback you read on TpT, this mentor sentences case study is for you!

If you are all about the numbers, then you are going to love what I have for you!

The short versionStudents who used mentor sentences grew more in style, grammar, and mechanics than students who did not.

Why mentor sentences

In the upper grades, mentor sentences provide students the opportunity to notice and imitate grammar and craft in well-written sentences from mentor texts you love and use in the classroom. This is your opportunity to stop teaching grammar in isolation and teach mechanics, grammar, and craft together in your writing time.

“Mechanics and grammar are inherently linked to craft… instead of separating them into different lessons, they should be merged whenever possible.”Jeff Anderson, Mechanically Inclined

By integrating your grammar and writing together, students will apply what they’ve learned to their own writing! I know this from my experience and from the experiences of others, but I wanted to give you some hard evidence, too.

How the writing was scored

I created a rubric to score all of the writing samples (used for beginning and end of the year samples from all students). Mentor sentences improve style, grammar, and mechanics, so those are the only areas I scored. This rubric was used to score the upper grade students:

Upper grades rubric scoring style, grammar, and mechanics at four levels: novice, developing, effective, and highly effective

In the lower grades, mentor sentences provide students the opportunity to read, learn vocabulary and/or grammar skills, and imitate grammar and craft in well-written sentences from mentor texts you love and use in the classroom. This way, students make the reading and writing connection!

This was the rubric specifically for K-2 students in the areas of style, grammar, and mechanics:

K-2 rubric scoring style, grammar, and mechanics at four levels: novice, developing, effective, and highly effective

What the mentor sentences case study found

Here are some great successes from the case study. Each number is the change in the percentage of students at that level, from the beginning to the end of the 2016-2017 school year.

Style

42-point gainin students scoring highly effective. That is 23 points more than students not using mentor sentences.

52-point gainin students scoring effective or highly effective. That is 25 points more than students not using mentor sentences.

Grammar

27-point gainin students scoring highly effective. That is 15 points more than students not using mentor sentences.

52-point gainin students scoring effective or highly effective. That is 21 points more than students not using mentor sentences.

Mechanics

26-point gainin students scoring highly effective. That is 19 points more than students not using mentor sentences.

42-point gainin students scoring effective or highly effective. That is 15 points more than students not using mentor sentences.

Tables of beginning and end of year style, grammar, and mechanics levels for students who did and did not use mentor sentences

Beginning and end of year levels for students who used mentor sentences (MS) and students who did not.

The biggest difference: how much students grew

What I found MOST impressive was the difference not just in the growth, but the AMOUNT of growth when using mentor sentences. Check this out!

Two or three levels of growth46% of the students who learned using mentor sentences improved in at least one area by two or three levels. That is 29 points more than the students who did not learn using mentor sentences!

Table of how many levels students moved: with mentor sentences, 42 percent moved two levels and 4 percent moved three; without, 16 percent moved two levels and 1 percent moved three

Get the complete case study

Using Mentor Sentences Created by Ideas by Jivey: Case Study

Download the complete case study to see more about specific grades as well.

Get the free case study

I hope this helps you see the difference mentor sentences can make in your students’ learning AND your teaching! You can see all of my mentor sentence products in my shop.

Keep reading

Get the mentor sentence lessons

Jivey signature
What does the data say about mentor sentences? A case study from Ideas by Jivey

Want more help with mentor sentences?